|
||
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
|
| 29er-26 | Brakes | Disc Brakes | Frame Materials | Hardtail-Full Suspension | Handlebars | Lights | Lube | Pedals | Rear Shocks | Saddles | Shifter | Shocks | ShocksII | Shorts | Tubeless Tires/Rims | Water Carrier | |
Date: March 14, 2006
DocPaul a weekend warrior from Flagstaff, AZ writes:
I'll break it down into clipless vs. platform. And my verdict is one is not superior to another, they are simply different. You want efficient xc riding, go clipless. You want technical FR/dirt jump riding, go platform. Never the twain shall meet.
Merits of clipless: efficiency efficiency efficiency. The only way you'll get power out of the complete pedal revolution. If you're a xc racer, riding long uphill fire roads, anything that requires long time in the saddle, then clipless is the only way.
Liabilities of clipless: gotta clip out NOW!!! If you gotta bail NOW, then clipless is suicide (no matter how "fast" you think you may be; how many dirtjumpers/FR riders do you see riding clipless???). If you have any need to shift the position of your foot on the pedal, you're outta luck. So much for pedalling on your heels!
Benefits of platform: technique technique technique. The only way to pull off trials/FR moves. Ever tried to manual or pedal hop or j-hop or bunny hop on clipless? HAH! Let's see you try to japslap even a 2 footer on spd's. (if you have no idea what I'm talking about, I rest my case, you clipless sissy). And for those of you who say you can bunny hop on clipless: you're delusional. You're merely "level hopping", not truly bunny hopping. (all you bmx-er's reading this, you know exactly what I mean).
Liabilities of platform: what? you can only use 50% of the pedal stroke? what? you mean you can bust open a shin bone? what? your feet bounce all over the place? what? you get sh*t for riding platforms from all your titianium lycra xc weenie riding buddies? How many xc gold medals have been won on platforms? Hmm? WWTD? (What would Tinker do?)
I vote tie. You like lycra? go clipless. You like full face helmets? go platform. You like both? get two bikes and two sets of pedals.
WINNER: Other
Time ATAC. Plenty of movement for the knee and a simple mechanism that's easily cleared of mud.
WINNER: Time ATAC
hate the lot of them prefer the good old platform pedals
WINNER: Other
I have em, I like em, and they work like a charm, only thing that I might want to complain about is the lack of platform, but when you find yourself needing that extra 2in of clearance, well, they are the best things you could ask for... Clip in, Clip out young Daniel...
WINNER: Shimano 747
Heh easy one here. CrankBros. rule bar none, nothin even in the same class!
WINNER: Other
100% perfec.
WINNER: Look S2R
Had knee pain before switching to 747. Pain went away and I have never regretted my decision. Five years later they still work perfectly although they have been hit hard and often.
WINNER: Shimano 747
Crank Brothers Eggbeaters over Time ATAC and Shimano 858s. Lube injection ensures that your pedal bearings stay in good shape, four-way entry means clipping in quickly and surely, lightweight design means no unecessary material.
WINNER: Other
Speedplays rule. I've ridden the 747s and the Ritcheys, but the Speedplays work the best. I've never had to worry about clogging of the springs. There is enough float for my knees. They are easy in, stay in, easy out.
WINNER: Speedplay
I use the Speedplay Frogs on my road bike because they are so easy on the knees. They have such good lateral float. I am very happy with these pedals.
WINNER: Speedplay
Knees love lots of float.
WINNER: Speedplay
I started off using the Shimano's But quickly switched to the Speedplays after one season and have not had one problem. Speedplay and crank Bro are the best out there
WINNER: Speedplay
PLATFORM!
WINNER: Other
There are only two pedals that any mountain bike rider would consider (DH aside). I use to only ride Time ATAC, they were the best pedal out there for many years, and are still a close second. But when CBros came out with the Eggbeater, they set the bar higher than the ATAC. The eggbeater lets you clip in on four sides, as opposed to only two with the ATAC pedal. They also retain absolutely none of the trail you are riding on. The eggbeater is also much lighter, you could nearly run two pairs for the weight of one pair of the ATAC pedals. Just think-eight sides that you can attempt to click that cleated shoe into.
WINNER: Other
platfrom=fr
fr=me
WINNER: Other
time atac, abused a set of aliums for 5 yrs before finally breaking a spring (1/2 worn through). dissasembled to clean and grease 1 time and when i got it apart, it didnt need a thing, even with a cracked spindle seal for the WHOLE time. just bought another new style set of aliums, i wanted a lighter set (atac carbon?) but just didnt know about plastic parts slamming into rocks, so opted for the heavier (and much cheaper) aliums.
WINNER: Time ATAC
No cloging
Cheap
Black
Cheap
Lots float
Made in France? Can't win em all
WINNER: Time ATAC
I've only ridden with the Time ATAC, but I have to say the ease with which I picked it up (relatively speaking), leads me to believe it's a good product. Function without problems in all conditions (I ride all year regardless of weather)and once you clip in and out a few times it becomes intuitive. Falling sucks but pedaling effeciency and being a better rider more then compensates. Would also consider the Crank Bros. Candy.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time ATAC XS for MTB & road (Time Control Z for DH)
easy in
stays in
easy out
works in any weather
mud proof
light
support
bottom line: easy in stays in
best all-weather technical singletrack pedals
we have five pairs
WINNER: Time ATAC
The best way to go is flat pedals. Clipless pedals are fine for roadies, but for mountain biking, that requires a higher degree of skill you need to be able to keep your feet on the pedals without cheating. Flat pedals make you a better rider. Hang loose.
WINNER: Other
The best way to go is flat pedals. Clipless pedals are fine for roadies, but for mountain biking, that requires a higher degree of skill you need to be able to keep your feet on the pedals without cheating. Flat pedals make you a better rider. Hang loose.
WINNER: Other
flats baby!!!!!!!! primo meat tenderizers
WINNER: Other
Tried Frogs could not get out of them soon enough to avoid crashes. Been using 747's for 5 years always seem to work good except for an occasional pop out. Tried Eggbeaters once felt like I was riding on ice cubes. Looking at the new Time ATAC carbons now.
WINNER: Other
Time ATAC. I considered all the Time's to be wussie French creations from my roadie days, until I tried these.
Big stable platform
Light (Carbon and Ti!!)
Great dirt release
Stomp entry
WINNER: Time ATAC
Speedplay... great float eases knee pain, low maintenance, and solid performance in any condition...! The Frog Ti's the best!
WINNER: Speedplay
Light, easy entry and exit, great on your knees. Great pedal for everyone, essential equipment for anyone with knee problems. Only weakness is that the mechanism doesn't clear grit (wet sand) well.
WINNER: Speedplay
I think that all of those pedals suck because you cant do freestyle and if you do and you ae about to fall off you cant bail as easily so thats why those pedals suck big cojones
WINNER: Other
eggbeaters!!!!! light, secure, UNCLOGABLE, reliable. Plus i hit a rock (fast and hard,like up wards of 25mph) and bent one of em, I clalled and asked if they could help me out even though it was in no way their fault and they said ABSOLUTLEY just to send it back and they would replace it, thats service and standing behind your product, i wont ride anything else as long as eggbeaters are still around
WINNER: Other
Eggbeaters... They're the easiest to clip into... and a snap to get out of. They're light and require no maintanance. How can you beat that?
EGGBEATERS!
WINNER: Other
I started with clips and straps "back in the day" -> got Shimano M737 when they first came out -> upgraded to M747 when they came out. They've been pretty good but I wore them out a couple of years ago. The latest Shimano SPD pedals are a downgrade to the 747s IMNSHO. After trying out every system I could get my hands on, I settled on Crank Bros. eggbeaters. They are fantastic!
The ultra-lightweight Ti models are crazy-expensive, but the "S" model is very light, very strong and good value for the money.
Good shoes are the other half of the equation: my choice are Carnacs - best fit (for my feet) plus super stiff soles and superb build quality.
PS One person claimed the eggbeaters are the hardest to clip out -- that is completely opposite to my experience...
WINNER: Other
Time ATAC because thay are bomb proof, have lots of float, they engage like butter and release when you whant them too.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time.
- Never a problem with mud or crud
- lots of float
- durable
- NOT shimano
WINNER: Time ATAC
In easily, out like magic, free float to protect knees and a grease port to make maintenance a snap. They're light, too! SpeedPlay FROGS!
WINNER: Speedplay
I'm on my third pair of ATACs.YOu Get in easily, they stay on for anything unles you just think of getting out! Like magic! You're out! What else do you want!
WINNER: Time ATAC
i likw the look s2r becuse thay are so light and good in the mud
thay match my bike with the caler of the bike you know?? i dig thim so much YOU ROCK LOOK keep it up your the best
WINNER: Look S2R
They just rock. I was hooked the very first time I rode them.
WINNER: Speedplay
Speedplay
Rode a pair of Magnums for 9 years on my hardtail..
Have ridden Frogs for 4 years on road bike...
Got a new FS bike this spring, tried stock Shimano's, hard to clip out; tried XPEDO, broken after 4 rides (extremely hard to clip out); tried Eggbeaters (perhaps the most difficult to clip out); got Frogs and became happy again (is there a lighter pedal out there?)
WINNER: Speedplay
they are all OK. I'd just buy a platform instead. very hard to un clip your feet to ditch your bike if needed
WINNER: Other
Egg Beaters. Good for breakfast and your heart.....also easy to get your feet in and out of....+ this is what I have and I like them.
WINNER: Other
I have tried both shimano style and ATAC style peddles, and i can honestly say that the times are a better choice, ease of entry, durability, and weight. ATAC carbon's are better than the aluminums.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I tried the ATAC. Call me weak kneed but I could have used some adjustability here, I crashed twice and that was it. The 747s were and have been my favorite pedal of all time, bar known. Light enough, adjustable, worked every time no matter the situation. Even my new 959s don't capture the allure of the 757s.
WINNER: Shimano 747
I currently use the shimano 747, and my only complaint is that they do not evenly adjust. In otherwords, if i adjust on side of the left pedal one way, when i flip it to do the same on the other side, it is completely different. I find myself always adjusting the clip, which is annoying. They are quite heavy also, which is not a good thing obviously for racing. I am looking into puchasing the Time Atac Titan Carbon set new for 2004. I have heard good things about them, so i am ready to cash in the shimano's and take a new route.
WINNER: Other
I've been riding the same pair of speedplays for 10 years.
Rebuilt them 2 times and replaced the cleats 2 times in those 10 years.
I've tried shimano and egg beaters but i love my frogs.
WINNER: Speedplay
I wear SPD's, in general they give a better feel of the bike, and much better acceleration. Though i did snap my elbow off after rotating backwards too much on a jump, this was due to the fact that i couldn't get my feet out. Other than that, on most crashes the feet will come out at lower settings. Flats are good for jumping, you can corner faster, and most people feel more comfortable on flats.
WINNER: Other
Atomlabs DHR!!!!
WINNER: Other
Is this a joke? The only pedals worth looking at are the Time ATAC's and the Egg-Beaters.
Of these, the beaters are lighter and the ATAC's work a little nicer. Personally, I use the beaters.
WINNER: Other
azonic xtension
WINNER: Other
None of the above.
Wellgo flats with Vans, or Airwalks!
WINNER: Other
Speedplay Frogs: Light, easy to use and durable.
WINNER: Speedplay
times all the way - I live in the mud, and for me, it's no contest.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Crank Brothers-Egg Beaters, Riding in the North West means riding in the MUD! Egg beaters are easy to clip in/out regardless of the conditions.
WINNER: Other
ive got shimano spds they are my first pedal but i think for wieght and simplicity i realy want to try eggbeaters
WINNER: Other
One of the most reliable and worry-free components I have on my bike. Don't have to think twice whether they'll work, or whether they'll release me when I need it most.
WINNER: Time ATAC
What do you need a platform for? Eggbeaters!
Muds not an issue, consistant release....
WINNER: Other
Haven,t tied any of these but just got eggbeaters, my first spd's, i love these pedals, put of getting for time all fears unfounded easy in easy out wouldn't go back, can't say for the rest of these pedals haven't tried
WINNER: Other
Egg beaters are the best hands down for the four sided entry. All you do is slam you foot down and its in no looking for the clip like those two sided entry pedals.
The best mudd shredding pedals in the clipless world!
Find on better you WRONG!!
WINNER: Other
Well me and two of my friends entered a competition. Two of us had the Schimano pedal and actually kind of a lot of experiance from riding bikes with SPD pedals. The other friend had his pedals mounted the evening before and had never even once tried SPD before. He had TIME pedals. Using Schimano we had trouble most of the time getting back in to the pedals due to mud and often even getting out of them as well. The beginner guy with TIME had no trouble what so ever. They worked like a dream. I�m going to buy TIME or eggbeaters. Schimano have other good bike components but not pedals.
;~}
WINNER: Time ATAC
Wow. All I can say is wow! I went to a local trail with a friend over the weekend to do some bicycling. He has a real nice bike, a Specialized hard tail (the kind without a back shock). Anyhow, he has some clip on pedals and let me take his bike for a ride. I had much improved power and speed compared to my black resin flat-type pedals. It was fun, I may get some for my self. I think people were checking out my pedals, which is an added bonus. Good equipment is the best way to go. I am revising my other review to vote for clip pedals.
WINNER: Other
Flats are the only way to go. dont ever have to worry about your feet not comming off, can wear any shoes with them. for dh, fr and jumping go flats. for you pussy xc lycra wearing riders out there clipless petals are nice for climbing because you can pull up on them as well as push down.
WINNER: Other
I am only a weekend rider. But I would some day like to get some clip ons for my bike. Right now I have regular plastic resin pedals because I am afraid I wouldn't be able to unhook from my bicycle when going up a hill with the fancier pedals. It's also easier to walk with regular athletic shoes, from what I hear. So for now I vote for Other pedals: plastic with good knobby-grip.
WINNER: Other
I've used SPD, Time, Eggbeater, and Frogs - and I've only broken my ankle once. I will never use SPD again.
All others deserve your consideration. I use Speedplay frogs because I know the cleat will break before my ankle will. I also like the float and no spring design of the frogs that is not offered by others.
WINNER: Speedplay
started w/ platforms, added powergrips (good training for clipless, if you can't go all the way at first), and use SPD clones now. SWEET ! Partner uses Times, real happy w/ them, but wore out cleats too fast. We both want Candy SL's, but he'll get 'em first, he doesn't have kids.
WINNER: Other
Egg beaters; quality, fit, and customer service.
WINNER: Other
crankbrothers! eggbeaters all the way.
WINNER: Other
clip petals suck.
WINNER: Other
Speedplay Frogs are hard to beat. Easy to get out of (most important thing on technical trails). Work well in all conditions, including mud). Tough, great clearance, lighter than Time ATAC's (Speedplay's only real challenger here). Did have to replace the cleats a couple of times(2000 dirt miles). The newly designed replacement cleat appears to be better designed as is supposed to last longer.
WINNER: Speedplay
plastic resin pedal with duct tape around the foot, nothin but power goin to the pedals
WINNER: Time ATAC
Speedplay wins. They are light, super reliable, great in mud, easy to get out of, easy on your knees,have excellent cornering clearance and the price has come down.
WINNER: Speedplay
In these choices, I'd pick the Times. I hate Shimano's system, a little bit of mud and they work like a pencil writes on glass! But my personnal choice is Crank Bros. pedals. I ride with a pair of Candy SL. They work well in any situation.
WINNER: Other
Eggbeaters rule! Mountain, road, mud, snow, whatever, they always engage and release perfectly, just the right amount of float, lightweight, easy to overhaul.
WINNER: Other
get platforms. mountain bikes shouldn't even come with clip in pedals. i fall off alot and think you aren't pushing yourself hard enough if you don't. the last thing you want in a fall is to be glued to the bike. but this is just my opinion. i wonder if there is any relation between the guys who like clip in pedals and the guys that prefer lycra over baggies.
WINNER: Other
Don't know about the others, but I can't imagine anything better than Time ATAC. Only been riding 4 months and reluctant to go to clip-ins. Tried them today for the first time and I'll never go back. Much much easier to get out of that I thought it would be.
WINNER: Time ATAC
The Time ATAC pedals are the greatest pedals I've ever ridden in any conditions, snow, mud, dust, rain, etc... I've been riding for 15 years and had Shimano and Ritchey Logic for most of the 15 years, I switched to Time two years ago and will never go back!! The easiest pedal to get in and out of, plus these pedals keep you in when you need it most. Great pedal for the money...none better.
WINNER: Time ATAC
like his name TIME TIME TIME ATAC ATAC ATAC........great this best
WINNER: Time ATAC
Just get ATACs, and be done with it. I sell them like crazy, and have never seen an operational failure. Why did I ever use spuds?
WINNER: Time ATAC
Egg beaters all the way!!
WINNER: Other
Sadly, you have not included the best pedal of them all: Eggbeater! Entry is brainless. They are consistent, firm and most of all... LIGHT.
WINNER: Other
Screw all of these choices, get Eggbeaters, they are far superior in just about every way possible.
WINNER: Other
Had 747's - good but heavy and occasionally unclipped at bad times.
Now have Eggbeaters...brilliant pedals. Light, four sides to clip in to, never come unclipped, do not get clogged. My left Eggbeater has had a rough bearing that started about a week after I got them, No Big Deal.
Crank Bros EggBeaters are the best pedal.
WINNER: Other
Atacs distroy 747s if there's any kind of mud or dirt. however I wore out the pedals (the retaining wire and wore down the pedal surfaces; I was using the aluminum ones). went through at least one set a year. I decided to give them up when I started pulling my feet out jumping out of corners in cross races, even with new cleats. I feel that the Shimano 959 is just as good in mud, and wears much better.
Plus I can use those old shimano pedals on other bikes (commuting, touring)
959.
WINNER: Other
Shimanos brake with rocks stuck in the clay mud on your cleats. Time ATAC are effortless and strong. 4 yrs. no problems. I give them hell on a Klein HT.
WINNER: Time ATAC
To be honest, i have not yet tried Crank Bros pedals. But i have no real reason to do so -- The Time ATAC pedals offer everything that i want in a pedal. they are tried and true in all conditions!
WINNER: Time ATAC
I had Time atac pedals 2 years ago and also I was riding with 747 and Ritcheylogic and the best were Times atacs especially in very deep mud!!! It was unbelivealbe!!!
WINNER: Time ATAC
One word: ONZA. Yes, they are old, out of business, the elastomers wear out, sometimes release, but they've gotten me through 20,000km of training every year for the past 3 years! Now put your shoes on, brush the dust off your bike, and go ride! If you don't like what you've got, then take off the pedals (and brakes while you're at it), point your rig down the steepest hill you can find, and jump on.
WINNER: Other
I use some cheap Ritchey Logic knock-off's and they get the job done for me. Never used ATAC's, my friends like em though. Speedplay are pretty good but not for atb and eggbeaters for atb are great. Easy to use but I broke my last set and replaced with cheapies.
WINNER: Other
i liked the speed play pedals over all the others. they were the easiestto clean in muddy conditions and are very reliable although they were more expensive than the richey.
WINNER: Speedplay
personally i like regular pedals my choice for clipless is obviously crank bros. but out of those choices i would choose either time or look
WINNER: Other
M545 Shimano rules! You can use even a flat shoes on it or even slippers! MKS Graphite also is a good choice.
WINNER: Other
Maybe this should be Clipless Vs. Platform Vs. Toe Strap.
WINNER: Other
Shimano 959
WINNER: Shimano 747
Crank Brothers Candys are the best, no problems covered in mud, water, anything, best pedals on the market
WINNER: Other
EGGBEATERS RUUULE, best mud clearance for my cleat, and 4 sided entry, the 2003 versions , i believe, hav all the kinks worked outta em.
WINNER: Other
I got me some platforms and some Powergrips and they work great. They haven't failed me yet, but I'm checking out the Crankbro's Candy SL.
WINNER: Other
Clipless pedal choice Shimano 959. Tore shafts out of Time carbon bodies from rock hits in Moab on XC rides. Cheesey bearings in Ritcheys. Speedplay Frogs lost one of the many cleat parts. Eggbeaters
are hard to use unclipped and will spin on your sole. Learn to bunny hop on BMX flat pedals and you discover its all in the hands not lifting at your feet.
WINNER: Other
Egg beaters, light, don't get clogged with mud and snow, never accidently unclipped...
WINNER: Other
hell ppl egg beaters!!!
WINNER: Other
Just one word: egg beaters
WINNER: Other
New to mtn biking. Bought a new bike that came with 515s. I had many wrecks due to not being able to unclip when needed. I thought it was a learning curve issue but so I kept trying to figure it out. I adjusted the tension and lubed them. i recently purchased a pair of crank brother candy sl. they work like butter, easy in, easy out. nice platform. lite. difference is like daylight and dark. never tried time, look or anything else but the candy sl are like butter.
WINNER: Other
Almost broke my hip and back during an over powered wheely clipped into my Ritchey V2's... painfull Still, that was driver-error, and the pedals unlocked before the snapped my anckles. Can't go freeridin on em...
WINNER: Ritchey Logic
Eggbeaters. Look 4x4 Eggbeaters at that. Extra bearing the frenchies shoved in there makes a big diff. Best pedal that you can forget about. I have em on my road bike (work great, not a crit guy so xtreme cornering not a concerning). I have em on my whamco big wheel. Looking fwd to putting CrankBros Mallets on the big-hit bike. "Shit no" pedals are the Windows ME of pedals. I had Ritchies - not great with little rocks or mud. Time - worked fine but heavy.. you Time ATAC guys should try eggbeaters - Eggbeaters same thing only better with the block of metal removed. Look S2R.. only if pull your sox up to your crotch. Speedplay does not make a mtb pedal, no matter what the marketing literature states. For the little punks who say clips are for fags, well maybe or maybe not sailor boy - send me some flowers.. but try doing a mountain century in yer tennis shooz, oh wait, that's right - yer drinking a redbull on a friggin chairlift designed for snowbunnies.
WINNER: Other
I tend to bunny hop around sharp corners and my Shimano 959s relased accidentally all the time, even with the tension cranked. I've switched to Eggbeaters and now it's easy in, easy out, and happy hopping. Let's hear it for Crank Bros!
WINNER: Other
i dont like any clip-in pedals becasue im a bmxer. one day i was riding my friends bike with his cleats and eggbeater pedals (he has a haro f4) on vert and i messed up on the pipe and couldnt jump off cuz i was clipped in. in the end i broke my ankle.
WINNER: Other
i lvoe my time atacs. they are reasonably priced and are great pedals. they have never come unclipped on me like my ritchey logics did. i'll never switch pedals again
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time all the way. Tried others and nothing comes close to comparing.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I have been ridin for 2 years, thousands of miles on my biike and one thing I notice when im ridin with buddies is that they always need to screw with their pedals. I have never needed to clean out, or never have had the pedals accidentaly unclip when im ridin. Paid $70 and never ever had to worry about my pedals. EVER!
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time after Time, the ATAC hold up, can take a beating, and yet little to no maintenance. I also cycle cross, so my ATAC's have been through mud, sand, rain, dirt, and assorted muck. Time is on your side.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time ATAC - Cause they work
WINNER: Time ATAC
Ritchey V.2s! The only ones I've had and I am very happy with them!! Easy in and easy out. I like the little bit of platform they have too!
WINNER: Ritchey Logic
I wouldn't spend a ton "o" money on glorious pedals, just use Shimano 515's for lock-ons or DMR platforms. Both cheaper pedals, both do the job.
WINNER: Other
I see that most who post here are comparing Shimano with TIME.......try the EGGBEATERS!!! 4-sided entry, light-weight, no maintenance....easy in easy out. Best pedal out there.
WINNER: Other
I have Time Control Z and love them. I used to be a Shimano user and I have used a few models before. Shimano's are great pedals as well but Time's are more positive in terms of clipping in & out plus they have more float. Time's are tougher to unclip to be honest but that's the price to pay for not getting any unintentional uncliping.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time pedals rule,the best in mud by far!
WINNER: Time ATAC
Had Ritchey Logics for 2.5 years. The SPD compatible was tricky to get into and my feet popped out at unplanned moments. Maintenence was needed far too often. NOT very good.
Swithed to Time ATACs. What an incredible difference! I clip in easily and STAY clipped until I want to get out! All I do is oil them from time to time.
The BEST!
WINNER: Time ATAC
Bebop is the way to go
WINNER: Other
Platforms. For sure.
WINNER: Other
All great riders are on Time.
WINNER: Time ATAC
the pyramid looks like this- platform (you fall off), toe-clips (you have to slow down to get in), anything other than CRANK BROS. B-A steps, the real McCoy- Egg beaters on all my rides are easy to learn to use and kick my ATAC (Alium and Carbon both sold)
WINNER: Other
I love these pedals! They are the perfect pedal. Clipping in is extremely easy and requires almost no force. The 20 degrees of float does not make your ankle position feel awkward or strained. Also there is no mechanism to gunk up with mud and maintenance is easy. Cleats are long-lived and durable. I will also agree with a previous comment that I have never remained connected to the pedal during a crash.
WINNER: Speedplay
Before my Time ATACs, I had only experienced SPD clones (Nashbar & Icon). I'm sticking with the ATACs. They're simple in design and simple in set up, cleat-wise.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I havn't ridden the others so I can't do much for a comparison but I've ridden Richey Logics for 5 years now with no problems. I think they've probably been a bit under-rated. I think because they are not the most expensive they get overlooked. but TRUST ME!!!! THIS IS A GREAT PEDAL!! I'm looking into getting some new pedals with a complete component upgrade but I'm tempted to stick with my richeys - they've been ultra dependable, maybe tougher than some on the entry but you stay in when you need to stay in, yet exit is EASY and the maintenance is next to nothing, durability is bombproof,and the Weight is decent. I also like the larger platform size. This was the perfect first clipless and though I havn't tried the others I'll probably stick with the ritcheys.
WINNER: Ritchey Logic
If you have to have clips to do well in BMX, why can't anyone(well almost anyone) beat me to the first turn on my flats?
WINNER: Other
Speedplay are the best. never had my feet stuck in them on a crash or near crash. let my wife use them and she kept them. tried time, but had trouble on quick releases. Had to go buy another pair of speedplays. Only problem is, I just ordered a Freeride bike, and don't know what to use for it. Speedplays aren't strong enough for that.
WINNER: Speedplay
I gave clipless a go and don't think they're worth the worry getting your feet free to save a$$. I got efficient with them as long as things were fast and dry. In technical or wet stuff I just could'nt get my feet out fast for the millisecond saves. There isn't always soft ground where you fall over stuck in the clips. I got pretty messed up just falling over on baby head rocks from a standing up position. So I am back with platforms and able to manage the wet, sloppy, technical and eveything else with 99% predictability. No more "can I unclip in time" anxiety.
WINNER: Other
I'm having second thoughts on my clipless pedals.I have eggbeaters and they work great until your on a really technical section and have to bail quickly and unexpectedly.I'm getting tired of laying on my back with my bike on top of me and my feet stuck in the pedals.I'm going back to platforms for my own safety.I guess years of racing bmx taught me to bail off instead of click my feet sideways.
WINNER: Other
I've been riding the same set of Ritchiey's for 12 years, believe it or not. They are so thrashed I can't believe the spindles are still in one piece. But they still spin smooth as butter, and release every time.
WINNER: Ritchey Logic
None i like the good ol' platforms
WINNER: Other
I have ridden a couple of brands of SPD pedals. I have switched to Egg Beaters. They can't be beat!
The entry and exit are sweet, and they hold through all kinds of bumps and bunny hops that my SPD's would let go in.
WINNER: Other
747! I have used Ritchey's before, and i broke off one of the retention wings! I am now using 747 and they work incredibly!
WINNER: Shimano 747
nothing beats the eggbeaters
WINNER: Other
I've used SPD's before, they're good and all but not as good as the Time's. The time;s have a bigger platform, easy to get into/out, self adjusting and still works even if its caked with mud. Simple and effective design.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Their all good but if your looking for a peadal with that u can clip out and still have a platform get time Z pedals they clip in like Time ATAC but give u a platform when needed
WINNER: Other
Well I bought my 747's used here on this site for $30 and have had them for about 2 years with no problems yet, I lube them and they perform well. They are as durable as you can get, they have taken numerous hits and still get me in and out of situations quickly.
WINNER: Shimano 747
time are heavy but they clip in with mud and snow. no other can say that
WINNER: Time ATAC
Ive tried Shimanos,Onzas,Looks and Time Atacs.Times are the best.You can get in or out no matter what and it doesnt matter what the conditions are.In the winter and spring here we get this clay type mud that seems to clog up everything,but not these pedals!I ride all year,whenever I have the time.Weather doesn't really matter to me.I like the float,especially in the rough sections.I've got 3 pairs of the Atacs,been using them for 4 yrs.now.I've changed bearings and springs on one set.Not hard to do.Make sure your cleats don't get too worn or you will blow out of the pedals in the rough stuff.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Eggbeaters. I've tried all the rest. Easy in/out. No accidental release in a year. Shed mud. No maintenance or adjustment. Light weight. Bullet proof. Cheap for the quality. I wish all the parts of my bikes worked as well.
WINNER: Other
Time ATAC wins hands down.
Only pedal with Lateral movement to allow your foot to settle into a more natural position + rotation.
Best for mud clearance
Nice big platform to support the foot gives better stability therefore less pressure on the knee joints
WINNER: Time ATAC
Tried Shimano, Ritchey but liked the Speedplay the best. Speedplay entry is stomp n' go vs. tiping your toe and mashing your heel. Click-in can be vauge though. No accidental release with these babies. Not even in the event of an emergency! Mud!? What mud! My knees like 'em too! Did I mention no accidental release? It also means they release when you need them to! I use the Ti Frogs...LIGHT!
WINNER: Speedplay
Time has to much float and my feet pop out too easily. I ride with shimano747!!!
WINNER: Shimano 747
The easiest of all the one-on-one surveys: Shimano 747's. Easy in, easy out. Wait a minute, that might acutally be a bad thing...
WINNER: Shimano 747
Time ATAC. no question about it. I have never had a single problem with them, never had to do any maintenance, no accidental unclippings, nothing. also, they handle mud like no other. I've piled mud on them and tried as hard as I could to clog them and I cant. Weight is a bit of an issue, but I'll sacrifice a few grams to have an all-around better performing pedal. I've tried SPD's and they are awful and I hear junk about speedplays. The only other pedal that I would consider buying if I needed new pedals would be egg-beaters.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I have tried shimano clipless, hated them in mud. Went to Times and love' em in springtime axle deep New England mud trails, easy in and out. However, I cannot smirk at those "platform" guys, because on a tight, rocky, uphill singletrack, I found even the ATAC leaving me on the ground still clipped in when I am doing a slow speed climb on a wet root/rock infested single track. I just bought a pair of platforms to ride in the winter, and I have to say, I like them very much. Really great when you hit a patch of ice. My personal conclusion based on what I have tried, is I will use platforms when in a tight rocky singletrack, and Time ATAC when on a longer, faster ride with lots of mud.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Only Time ATAC on any of my rides... enough float to be extra kind on the knees... eassy in, out... and the mud performance rocks
WINNER: Time ATAC
Used Shimano, but too many problems in the mud. Went to Time- great in the mud, but more difficult for general entry and the plastic plate under the cleat "gouges" out and allows your ankle to rotate outward which was hard on my knees. The plastic plates also crack easily. Finally, Speedplay and they are easy entry no matter what the conditions, and knee-friendly float. It's a little strange to get used to at first- like your feet are on ice, but now it is great. Best pedals out there!
WINNER: Speedplay
Had SPD pedals and got ATACS a few weeks ago.
Much easier to engage AND disengage + perfect
mud clearance!
WINNER: Time ATAC
BMX Flats all the way baby!
WINNER: Other
Just one question. Why wouldn't you want the Times?
WINNER: Time ATAC
um, i sold my pedals. With that extra cash i was able to get some pretty snazzy reflectors.
WINNER: Other
Flats with toe-clips rock - easy in, easy out - I'm contstantly overtaking posers on clips who get out of shape in corners (mostly singletrack) and can't correct their balance quick enough.
They may look a bit Old Skool, but who cares.
WINNER: Other
Time ATAC pedals clear mud so much better than the Shimano pedals that I used to ride. They also give a better platform for starting out on an incline. Easier to get in and about the same to get out of. I've only ridden Shimano's and Time but if I had to choose I'd absolutely say Time.
WINNER: Time ATAC
SHimano works better and has more adjustments. But I ride in the winter and do cyclocross, so I use Time, because I can always get into them. If it wasn't for that, I would use shimano.
WINNER: Time ATAC
time, time, time, time, time, time atac carbon
WINNER: Time ATAC
TIME IS SHIT!!!!!!
WINNER: Shimano 747
shinburber platfroms
WINNER: Other
Time ATAC (Carbon) is easy to clip in and out, no accidental clip-outs, no maintenance required, perfect for all weather riding..
Its the best..
WINNER: Time ATAC
hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm i go with platforms
WINNER: Other
Can't say much on Speedplay since I haven't ridden them. As for the Shimano 747,Ritchey Logic, and Look S2R, I can't stand them. Had to borrow a comprable pair once for a race and spent most of my time just trying to get clipped in. I'll stick with my Time ATAC Comp's. They may be a bit heavier, but I never have trouble getting in or out and the float they offer makes my knees happy. There's a reason why they are so popular on the World Cup circuit...
WINNER: Time ATAC
Had Shimano 747's and switched to speedplay frogs, the free float of 26 degrees is awesome on the speedplays, I really don't know how shimano sells any pedals with the speedplays out there, much, much better!, to say the least.
WINNER: Speedplay
I used to ride with clips all the time but 6 months ago I made the transition to flats and have never looked back. For me I feel my bike handling has improved and I can bunny hop a lot better now. Yeah it's all personal tastes but I don't like that feeling of being clipped in on a very technical part of a trail. Oh and before I forget buy some shin protection as flats hurt if your foot slips.
WINNER: Other
Meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh meh!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Platforms rock
WINNER: Other
I like platforms cause u can bail and stuff. I do not like clipless cause you can't bail and stuff. Try pulling a no footer with clipless pedals.Meh. Meh. Meh Meh. Meh Meh.
WINNER: Other
i have used all the pedal but speedplay and they just look too weak for my riding style. Time ATAC are my favorite no adjustment work well in mud and techincal areas never rust. Times take a beating and want more.
WINNER: Time ATAC
i have the carbons. they are strong, need no adjustment and half the year where it is always raining.they work great in mud.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I've been using the Frogs for 3 years now and would be hard pressed to find anything i like more. Easy to clean, easy to use. The first month I had a minor problem with getting the screws set for the proper tightness, and lost one screw somehow but the shop was able to find a replacement screw for me. But since then, everything's been perfect. Even when I disengage in the middle of the trail, it's fairly easy to get back in.
WINNER: Speedplay
Ritchey Logic... Hands DOWN dog. O maintenance in over 6 years. After rocks, roots, bricks and everything else....
WINNER: Ritchey Logic
If you could see some of the crazy places my bike has taken me - like 6 feet in the air or down a root infested drop off - you would not want to be strapped to it. All of these pedals are probably great for XC/road but not for free ride or DH. Although, I must admit that it is nice to finally have a comparison that doesn't start the dreaded XC vs. DH/FR war!
Platforms and an eject button!
WINNER: Other
Time ATAC get my money but they need to loosen up a bit. Hard to get out of after a crash.
WINNER: Time ATAC
PLATFORM IS THE BEST!!
WINNER: Other
Ive been using VP pedals108s these are similar to Shimano 747 in appearance but were alot cheaper and good value but Shimano 1sided 525 spd which I have also used seem to be better on entry and exit then the Vp108s i havent used any of the pedals listed here so shimano doesnt get it plastic bits no good VP entry exit isnt that good so about =
WINNER: Other
CRAAAAAAAANK BROOOOOOOOOOOS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THE BEST.
I've owned Shimanos, Times, and Bontragers and all I can say is
CRAAAAAAAANK BROOOOOOOOOOOs!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THE BEST.
WINNER: Other
uh... My bike did not come with pedals so I just don't use them.
WINNER: Other
Man, look at my name...I just bought some Speedplay Frogs (since I like my road pedals so much) to replace my Onza, which by the way are still going stong on my "chase the kids around the block bike"
WINNER: Speedplay
727 all the way they come in and out soo easily
WINNER: Shimano 747
Shimano 646. They are easier to get into than anything I've tried (other than flats) and if they fill up with mud you can still stand on them (umm... like flats). Set them up loose and they're easy to get out of when you need to (but not quite as easy as flats). If I didn't suck so bad at bunny-hops already, I'd probably get myself a pair of flats...
WINNER: Other
flats goddammit
WINNER: Other
TIME ATAC all the way.
Easy to get in and out of. Mud is not a problem. You don't have to do any maintenance.
I'm surprised how tough the composite/plastic is. After almost 2 years of banging on rocks and roots there are only a few chips.
Only bad part is they cost about $100.
Check out the new Time ATAC "Z" pedal, looks like a combo clipless and platform.
WINNER: Time ATAC
clipless blow balls get flat pedals
WINNER: Other
ATAC is the only true performer for clip-ins. No sticking,or inabililty to unclip in the pinch. The ATAC's give a great amount of float, and reduce alot of knee stress.
They cost a few more bucks, but as they say " you get what you pay for"!
WINNER: Time ATAC
Crank Brothers -Crank Brothers - Crank Brothers.
Look no further, try these and you never go anywhere else. They have won the respect of all the Bicycle magazine Editors...and they deserve it.
WINNER: Other
FLATS!!
WINNER: Other
PLATFORMS
WINNER: Other
Personally, I like Platform pedals. I like the freedom of foot and ankle, and im not all that great so its easier to bail. Maybe ill get one of these later on in my riding but im for platform for now.
WINNER:
EGG BEATERS!!!!
I started on Shimano then went to Frogs cause I thought I'd try something lighter, then went to Times cause the Frog's cleats kept breaking, then went to eggbeaters cause the Times were a pain to get into and my foot kept sliding sideways. I don't think I'll ever give up the Crank Bros. They have smooth entry and release, they're lighter and cheaper than anything else and there's nowhere for mud to stick.
WINNER: Other
GOSTARIA DE RECEBER E-MAIL SOBRE PRE�OS E ENDERE�OS DE BIKES, TREK E SCOOT. AGRADE�O DESDE J� !
WINNER: Shimano 747
Pedals suck. I don't use em.
WINNER: Other
No doubt about that Time, big mud no problem for Time always clicking
WINNER: Time ATAC
SpeedPlay rule, light weight..step in..twist out...only limited exit on inside..tried BeBob's...hung on exit.
WINNER: Speedplay
consistent in-out in all conditions...
no maintenance in three years and counting...
have tried the shimano's and the wannabees, their predictability changes the longer the ride goes on
WINNER: Time ATAC
But don't waste your money on the carbon fiber platforms or the Ti axles. The Aliums are the ticket. Nice solid platform, easy in/out in all conditions, great price. I had the carbon fibers ones for about 2 years and they split into two pieces in a rock garden. The Aliums should take their lumps better at half the price.
WINNER: Time ATAC
OK, depending on what kinda od TIME pedals you are talking about, creates different opinions. The titans and aliums are nice, but the carbon just plane suck! I used them for 3 months of training and by the end there was no pedal left! Dont pland on using them again. I then used some ritchey's, like them a lot. only reason i got rid of them is becasue they broke, minor accident, but ritchey replaced them with some Speedmax pedals...love them the most. After trying my friends shimano 959's, WOW, I LOVE THEM. what a fun pedal., dont plan on using anything else now, and compared to the 959's, TIME pedals blow.
WINNER: Other
Without a doubt Time ATAC. Easy to get in and out of, mud wont clog them, some lateral play for pedal position. They seem to work even better as you use them. Tried SPD's before, nice because of tension adjuster, but i'd say SPD's are good for beginners trying clips for the first time. But SPD's just done feel 'secure' enough when clipped in.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Clears mud better than any previous pedal & no screws to fall out.
WINNER: Time ATAC
flats beat them all if you have the skills to use them properly.
WINNER: Other
The ATACs are vitually indestructable. Their mud performance is unparalelled and maintenance is negligible.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I love my 747's and intend to keep them going as long as I can- I have the appropriate tools for servicing them. I got them second hand for about US$ 30.
WINNER: Shimano 747
New to mountain biking but avid roadie. On the road I use speedplays. On the road there is no equal. I have not yet tried the frogs on my MB. I am using the shimanos with the SH55 cleat which allows me to exit from a number of different angles which is important to me now since I am just getting started. My views may well change as I become more experienced. I think the problem with frogs and the ATACs is going to be trying to get out in situations where it is difficult to swing my heal out, for example on a steep uphill with lots of pressure on the pedals and stalling out while out of balance.
WINNER: Shimano 747
I used Carbon Times for 4 months, thinking one day I'd be able to get out of them quickly when I needed to. No dice. Those things are a bitch to get out of if you stall on a climb or other situation. Then I tried the frogs. Easy in, easy out. I mean really easy out! It take ZERO effort to get out of the Frogs. And they keep you clipped in great! Funny I never see anyone with Times on the trails, but always see SPD's and Frogs.
Frogs are the only way to ride.
WINNER: Speedplay
The best in mudy conditions. Very reliable. Bomb proof !.
WINNER: Time ATAC
i love the time atac that is the only pedal i will run.. it gives u a nice degree of float and easy release. cant wish for anything better
WINNER: Time ATAC
Easy in and out, lot of float, best for rinding in mud and do not have to worry about any adjustment at all. But it's not light even the Ti model.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Kona flats own you.
WINNER:
Time Atac, have not failed me yet! Simple and can take the abuse, nice amount of float to boot!
WINNER: Time ATAC
I bought some performance topo-7 (cause they were 20 bucks)as a first clipless. I love the pedaling action, but if you get bumped around your coming out. I was more secure on platforms and can't figure out why every one is so anctious to buy pedals that wont hold if you twist, jump, or get bumped around. These are for rodie fags.
WINNER: Other
If you want a great pedal, buy Shimano PD-M646. I ride on them and I guarantee that they are the best pedals if you don`t care that your bike is a few grams heavier.
WINNER: Other
where the the flats!!!!!!!!!!!! shimano DX
WINNER: Other
Hands down, TIME Atac.
Mud can't clog.
Lube isn't neccessary.
Break them on rocks? Nah.
Knees don't hurt anymore.
WINNER: Time ATAC
what, no Platforms?
if i had to choose from the pedals above, I would say Time ATACS(used about 2 years), more reliable than the SPD system, and hey they're not Shimano. On the other hand i think the SPDs are good for newbies to clipless, cause you can adjust how easy/hard they are to get out of.
for long rides: Time ATAC
for trials / messing around: platforms
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time ATAC is where it is at. I have owned Shimanos and Ritchey Logics before. Atacs are far superior especially in mud.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I never liked any pedal that secured me to my bike. I ride to be free, not imprisoned in a set of suck-ass pedals. When mine break I just go to Wal-Mart and buy another set for only $9.97. I am the best mtb ryda in da world. Clips are for posers.
WINNER: Other
Times rule. A simple pedal designed to last. Works superior in any condition.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I used to use the Time carbons (great pedal), but Speedplay's are the best, I use the Ti frogs which are 200g less than 99.9% of pedals out there, they also shed mud better. Ultimately it's the feel that decides this eternal question. Time lover's, try the frogs.
WINNER: Speedplay
Haven't tried the egg beaters, but my Times are awesome. I had some shimano clones before (garvin brand), and they were far inferior in the mud. But besides the mud shedding, the Times have zero adjustment. No popping out of the pedal because the tension isn't set just right! That's worth the price of admission right there. The only thing I'd to improve would be entry - I have no trouble clicking in unless I really need to right then, in which case clicking in is almost impossible. This seems to be the case with most any 'clipless' pedal though.
WINNER: Time ATAC
747's are by far the better of the bunch,Speed Play; your foot comes disingaged if your an agressive technical rider, Ritchey; to heavy collect mud
WINNER: Shimano 747
Shimano rules ..the very Best,the new EGGS pedals are shit ,I tried them -Egg Beaters the worst pedals ever !-racing and i couldn�t take out my feet while i was racing even i got problems with them allover the race but then i got a hell of a crash !!F### eggs ,, don�t buy eggs ????? buy the Real thing SHIMANO .
WINNER: Shimano 747
I bought a set of ritcheys' and had a little trouble threading the left one. Two weeks later it simply slid out of my crank. Turns out it was stamped "L" but was threaded RIGHT! So I'm out the pedals ( which I never liked to begin with) and the crank which is now worthless. Time atac is where it's at, easy clip in mud or no mud.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I bought a set of ritcheys' and had a little trouble threading the left one. Two weeks later it simply slid out of my crank. Turns out it was stamped "L" but was threaded RIGHT! So I'm out the pedals ( which I never liked to begin with) and the crank which is now worthless. Time atac is where it's at, easy clip in mud or no mud.
WINNER: Time ATAC
the Look S2R woop. i use em and ive been winnin alot now!!!!!!
WINNER: Look S2R
Ritcheys suck ass...ever try to jump w/ them...broken bones here you come...Shimano's not bad but crappy when it gets muddy...Speedplay can have the same problem...no opinion on Look other than they seem like carbon copies of Ritcheys and Shimanos...if you really want a good simple pedal that holds you when you really need them to and don't care if your in the desert or in a swamp then go no further than Time...best damn pedal I've ever ridden...hands down.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I like the ritcheys because they de-gunk very well, don't weigh a ton, don't cost a lot, offer solid and predictable performance, and are compatible with absolutely any spd cleat.
WINNER: Ritchey Logic
Hey! Where are the egg-beaters?
WINNER: Other
I'll be damned if I know why no one likes floatless pedals? I Can't belive I'm the only one. I can't stand float. I kinda feel like I'm trying to rassel a greased pig between my legs. 737 are the only ones for me. Not because there any better that any other pedal, but because w/ ,I think it's with the, 51 cleats they have no float. I have 2 pr. of 737s & I'm hanging on to them like gold. I wish father God Shimango would make an up dated pedal w/ zero float.
WINNER: Other
atac all the way. i stepped in with an inch of mud on the bottom of my shoe and it felt pretty much the same releasing as normal. enough said
WINNER: Time ATAC
747's were good but horrible in mud
Ritcheys were just plain horrible
looks had durability issues
Times, can't beat em, they are heavier than some, but great mud performance and time proven design. When 70%+ of the pros are riding them they are good, cause time sure isn't paying all of them to ride them.
WINNER: Time ATAC
I started riding clipless pedals with the free ones i got at the shop I worked at. RITCHES, red. I immediatley saw and felt the benifits of clipless. One ride a racing buddy of mine suggested the ATACs and baby they are the best, most comfortable, easy-in, easy-out, no mud clogging, lots of float pedals. I love them. I RECOMMEND THEM.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Magnesium platform pedals with replaceable traction pins are the best all-around usage devices for my needs for technical riding, walls, beams, jumps, drops, etc where I may have to bail quickly if I lose my balance. They are as light as most clipless pedals, and I dont have to worry about getting stuck in them when trying to bail off my bike on a rooftop to save my neck. You get what fits your riding style best and it's all good. All these pedal choices work well for different situations.
WINNER: Other
wellgo rocks and they dont cost the leg that you need to ride them with
WINNER: Other
I've tried the ritchey's, not bad but just didn't feel very sturdy.the Time ATAC's were excellent except the release was scary on them (not adjustable).I ride Shimano 515's they work great, are cheap (30.00 bucks)take a beating, and are fully adjustable. so many brands out there with alot of hype & Shimano still makes some of the best parts.
WINNER: Shimano 747
I rode the Ritcheys for two years and then switched to platforms. Never went back.
WINNER: Other
I've ridden lots of pedals. And the ones that are the stiffest and the easiest to clip into are the Time ATAC, they are d'bomb. I tried Egg Beaters and the damn things were like pedaling on a stick of licorice, to whippy, The Alium Time's are a little heavier then the carbons and and a lot stiffer. They's my choice hands down. Crank On!
WINNER: Time ATAC
I just got a set of the crank bros. egg beaters and they are untouchable. These things shed mud faster then any pedal out there. Times are close but still not as good. Time and shimano both have some of the best pedals but crank bros. just out did them.
WINNER: Other
Time Atac's are tight. easy to get in and out of shed mud pretty good just bought a pair but have been using friends for a while
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time ATAC allthe way baby!
WINNER: Time ATAC
Shimano pedals are great. will not lie about that, but they just arent practical enough however i do have them on most of my bikes.
Time pedals just seem to crack under fatigue. I've heard of so many cases and know so many people who have done it.
I choose Speedplay cause i ride my bike ALOT and this causes alot of knee pains. Chose Speedplay for the Free Float feature and could not be happier. These aren't designed for big hits but handle 10's of thousands of kms. grease injector port is a handy feature
WINNER: Speedplay
I tried Ritchey - the worked 'good', however when I removed them to clean & lube the threads - the threads stripped. The crank arm was fine - so I hung them on the wall and tried Time ATAC. i loved them - they worked great in all conditions. I wear out cleats fast - the replacements are'nt too expensive and you have adjustability in the exit angle with the cleat mounting.
I race started racing BMX after some time on mountain bikes - I run the Times on my BMX bike and love them there too! I also found out a nice reason to run clipless - my wife was going to loan one of my bikes to a neighbor (13 yr old) and she had it down from its resting place when she realized it had "...thoose funny pedals on it..." so she changed her mind and did not give my race bike the loaner treatment. Man I thought WOW! that was a close call.
Here is the hard truth - do what is right for you. Try what you can afford and experiment. Ride different bikes and try new riding styles. Challenge yourself and you will find new ways of doing the same old grind. Be you - don't react to ratings - just go do it!
As for me? Every crank arm in my shop has knows what Time it is ... and that may have saved thier life!
WINNER: Time ATAC
Nothing can beat Time's abilities in muddy situations, I'll stick with them till the end.
WINNER: Time ATAC
These things never miss. Tons of mud and I am right in them, my SPD buddies were squirtin with water while I am going down the trail. Good amount of float to boot. Just plain good!!!
WINNER: Time ATAC
non
WINNER: Look S2R
lets see
747s work well if it's not muddy
ritchey, the ones i've had experience with didn't last very long
speedplay, yeah the pedals light, that's becuse the bulk is on the bottom of your shoe
never used looks
WINNER: Time ATAC
Damn IT!!! I just wrote two paragraphs comparing each one of these stinking pedals then hit the "minimize" button.. and lost it all! Now i'm too frustrated to rewrite it. Basically.... if you're looking for lightweight, durability, reliability, servicability, made in the usa, superior performing pedals... go with the frogs. Unless you live in B.C. and expect to take 10-15 drops, ditching your bike frequently, and generally enjoy abusing yourself.... then bmx style pedals with lotsa grippy little pegs on them would work better. Also... the composite body of the frogs may not be able to take hard bashes against rocks (although if you can manage to do it without claiming the life of some other part of your bike i'd be impressed) My only complaint is that when it gets extremely cold... ice tends to form... when ice forms... you stomp on the pedal to crack the ice... over time this tends to also crack the composite plastic body of the frogs. (I've replaced mine once... (for free) after 2 years of extreme winter riding)
WINNER: Speedplay
Time Atac all the way there a simple design. They don't get all gummed up with mud there easy to work on. The list goes on and on. Iv'e owned Shimano pedals and they suck compared to these. The time's don't lose tension I have had mine for over a year and a half and I won't ride with anything else.
WINNER: Time ATAC
obviously....
WINNER: Time ATAC
The new Shimano 959, all friggin day long, I am incapable of putting this strongly enough! You must own them,... yesterday!
WINNER:
clipless peadals suck!!!
WINNER: Other
clipless peadals suck!!!
WINNER: Other
Shimano 858 is the winner, never slips out, easy to mount, no problem at all i muddy conitions.
Vp only slips out dont waste moeny on them.
WINNER: Other
Time ATAC- they are the easiest to get in and out of, they keep mud out, they are light, and they look cool...
WINNER: Time ATAC
Have u seen Crank Bros egg beater peddles? Wow theyre cool man!!
Minimalist, and makes the rest look so complicated an unneccessary in comparison!
WINNER:
Time ATAC, No contest
WINNER: Time ATAC
74747474747474747474747474747474747474747474747474747's!!!!!!!! Take a lickin' and keep on tickin'! Over 6 years of trusty, reliable service!
WINNER: Shimano 747
Speedplay...lightest on the market., excellent in mud, easy in, easy our, easy maintenence (with grease post)and lost of float...great on the knees. In all fainess I have never ridden Time ATAC's...but being a speedplay owner for three years, I know I'll never have to...I'm way too satisfied!!
WINNER: Speedplay
Its all about the Times. They wil never ghost unclip on you. It is such a secure pedal. You can hop over 1 foot tall logs with out slowing down. Hopping will never be the same for you if you get these pedals.
WINNER: Time ATAC
PLATFORM!
WINNER: Other
LOOK S2R!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
WINNER: Look S2R
I ride big heavy bmx style flat pedals. No clips but big sharp pins. I know that I loose a whole lot of pedal power and some height on a bunny hop, but i like the control i get in a slow technical balance situation. I can turn my feet any way that i want to retain my balance, keep my feet on the pedals and continue to roll where as a clip-in pedal you might have to unclip and dab a foot. Plus if you do have to dab a foot with flats it is that much quicker. But WTF, it is whatever works for you, but flat pedals look damn cool, and you can do nac - nacs and other sweet tricks. E-SIDE FREE-RIDE!!!!!!!
WINNER: Other
I have rode in just about every kind of conditions imaginable and nothing compares to the reliability of the TIME ATAC. Nothing stops these pedals snow, mud, water, and dirt. In races it is the one peice of equipment I don't have to worry about. I will never own another pedal.
WINNER: Time ATAC
No contest - TIME Rocks
WINNER: Time ATAC
Simply the best. Nothing more needs to be said
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time ATAC all the way! Mud performance is awesome.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time ATAC are they best , Mud is no problem, easy in and out forsure. and they look nice to boot....
WINNER: Time ATAC
Easy in, easy out, stays clean, and simple.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Rode with clipless for years in the 90's, now it's flatties all the way.
DK Iron Cross pedals are PHATT.
others are good too.
WINNER: Other
i ride 515s but if i had the money id be riding time atac carbons. I liked speedplay at first but I don't think ineed that much float. Richtly and looks are pretty much jsut shimanos with a different body.
WINNER: Time ATAC
speedplay are the stupidest pedals I've ever seen. instead of having a small cleat on your shoe, and a clip on your petal, it's just reversed. You've got this big bulky clip on your shoe, that gets in the way, gets filled with dirt, and still ends up weighing the same amount.
WINNER: Shimano 747
Times work much better than the SPD's I used to use. Customer service is tops also. I had a problem with the left pedal and they sent a new pedal and replaced the seals and repacked the bearings in the other pedal. They work consistantly and are great in mud.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Nice click, nice float, sheds mud, makes me happy.
WINNER: Time ATAC
you know how we do it..kinda heavy but the best out there
WINNER: Time ATAC
shimano 747 easy adjusting and enterance and exiting
WINNER: Shimano 747
The plastic pedals on Huffys are the best ones out there. So Cha Cha Cha! Peanutbutterman out.
WINNER: Other
The plastic pedals on Huffys are the best ones out there. So Cha Cha Cha! Peanutbutterman out.
WINNER: Other
Speedplay wins hands down. Lots of float, LIGHT, and very easy to enter and exit. Shimano is lame because you have to adjust the tension, Times are nice too. Look and Ritchey, never tried and probably never will. Happy trails.
WINNER: Speedplay
When the Apocalypse comes, all the techno-weenies who get stuck in their clipless pedals and can't run away because of the goofy shoes will be washed away in a sea of hydraulic fluid. We will all then come to our senses and start riding steel hardtails with PowerGrip staps.
WINNER: Other
I had Bontrager RE-1 that came with my Sugar2 and it sucked big time, it was hard to engage or disengage and came off when it wanted. I replaced them with Time ATAC and almost immediately bacame natural instinct and no adjustment needed (I've never used clipless before). BTW they are indestructible and maintenance free, mine are almost one year old and are good as new.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time ATAC all the way. Best mud performance, most durability, best all-around performer.
WINNER: Time ATAC
The plastic pedals on Huffys are the best ones out there. So Cha Cha Cha! Peanutbutterman out.
WINNER: Other
Never had a problem with 747s. Just pays to adjust the release properly.
WINNER: Shimano 747
Very predictable. Easy entry and exit. Not as easy to enter as the ATACs, but MUCH easier to get out of in a bind.
WINNER: Ritchey Logic
Times every day, easy to use great performance what else can you want...
WINNER: Time ATAC
Gotta say that the Rockies support Shimano. Nice and dry until mid-winter-riding mud screws up and closes trails. Had Time pedals come into my shop ruined (springs loosened) after one season. Cut my teeth on Ritchey's, but have seen the light. Speedplay good for road and cross. Look at what?
WINNER: Shimano 747
I will fly in the face of convention and vote Ritchey.Mine have held out great in the snowy,muddy shitfield that is the Northeast.Once you break them in(someone said it was like kick-starting a motorcycle,and I agree)they're very good consistent pedals for a fraction of the Times' price.I bought them to replace the shitbox Bontragers that came on my Trek 7000.NEVER,EVER,EVER BUY BONTY RE-1'S AFTERMARKET!!I broke them(yes,BROKE THEM)riding cross-country and I only weigh 160 pounds!
As for downhill racing(the Trek is my fitness/training bike),I gotta vote for platforms.The downhill racing scene around here is super-technical,and for most courses clipless pedals actually slow you down--makes picking around in technical sections A LOT harder.Yeah,there are some courses in which clipless is an advantage,but good pedaling technique makes up the difference. Shinburgers,Zu-zu's,Eastons,Atomics--all work good.Once you learn how to spin just right,you'll never do clipless DH racing again!
WINNER: Ritchey Logic
747 = knee problems
time = I some time skit out (othervice good )
speedplay = big positiv surprise under ALL condisions
WINNER:
Had the 747's, Ok pedal but not enough float and was tough on the knees, bought the Looks, lots of friction. Switched to Frogs, hated them for the first three rides got used to them by the fifth and loved thm on the sixth. Great float, easy out and two seconds or less to clean.
WINNER: Speedplay
TIME ATAC for sure. Shimanos are to fragil and I've broken a pair on the inevitable slam against a rock. My ATAC seem almost bullet proof. They take incredible bumps against rocks and show no loss in performance.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time ATAC hands down....
What's up with all of the XC-knocking downhillers on this site??? Downhilling is a hell of a rush, but it doesn't make you anymore of a man just because you CLAIM to be a die-hard downhill rider! You have to work both you're downhill and XC skills are both important unless you through your bike in the back of a truck everytime you have to climb a mountain. Get a life, and turn the testosterone down a couple of notches...
WINNER: Time ATAC
shimano, easy to get out of, handles mud well
WINNER: Shimano 747
used Ritchey pedals for years, pretty happy except in extreme mud. Switched to time aluminum. A little trouble getting out at first, takes some breaking in time, very secure. Easy in and snugg with good float.
WINNER: Time ATAC
clipless suck unless you are a xc racer. Get atomic platforms.
WINNER: Other
The float, light weight and (dry)easy entry-exit make these my favorites after having used spds for years.
WINNER: Speedplay
The float, light weight and (dry)easy entry-exit make these my favorites after having used spds for years.
WINNER: Speedplay
I like time over my shimano
WINNER: Time ATAC
I have owned both Shimano and Ritchey and Speedplay pedals. The Shimano pedals were great for the 2 years I rode them. Ritcheys were shit. Hard to get into and released way to easy. The Speedplays are the best. Easy entry and they never release when I don't want them to. They also have the most foat so they are easy on the knees. Kinda pricy though.
WINNER: Speedplay
I race and train with my Time ATAC carbons, god!! use to have look SL2's but the kept getting mud and stuff clogged up in them. And Kashi Leuchs, Cadel Evans, Miguel Martinez, they all use them and pros dont use shit
WINNER: Time ATAC
I race and train with my Time ATAC carbons, god!! use to have look SL2's but the kept getting mud and stuff clogged up in them.
WINNER: Time ATAC
The SpeedPlay Frogs are great pedals. Secure latching, yet easy clean float. Super light, yet hold up YEARS under my 200+ lbs (steel axles) and are easy to lube with the greaseport. I tore mine apart (easy) after 6 years, just to see how the bearings were--totally fine. The greaseports and purge system works great. Cleats are EXPENSIVE, but last a long time.
WINNER: Speedplay
NO REPLACEMENT FOR THE FROGS! TO USE OTHERWISE IS UNWISE!
WINNER: Speedplay
SHIMANO 747's are what I ride. I got them for next to nothing and the work great. I would like to try the others too.
ritchey suk, speedplays are for roadies. looks & times are both excellent pedals as well.
WINNER: Shimano 747
normal unlocking pedals are the way to go
WINNER: Other
I know Times are good ,(I have some) but I got on this site to check out the Shinburgers. So where are they? I wouldn't buy 747's if you paid me. But I do like the 636's though. I suppose I need to check "other".
WINNER: Other
I know Times are good ,(I have some) but I got on this site to check out the Shinburgers. So where are they? I wouldn't buy 747's if you paid me. But I do like the 636's though. I suppose I need to check "other".
WINNER: Other
well, frankly i've never used these things... just classic metal peddles. If i caught my self paying 150 bucks for some peddles i'd have to kick my self in the ass. Plus special shoes you're up to about 220 depending on the quality. I could upgrade my whole drive train for that much, plus get some better rims and a better hub! But if you've won the lotto like some dude here, awesome... but if i won the lotto, i'd be riding a dirt bike, not a mt bike.
WINNER: Other
Time pedals are great! Simple is good.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Time Pedals are the best. Mud proof, lots of float, and durable. soon to be the standard.
WINNER: Time ATAC
The Time ATAC were my first clipless pedal, so I have no base of comparison with another manufacture. I can't imagine another pedal being better though. The Time is easy to get into and out of, even for a beginner like myself.
WINNER: Time ATAC
Just better!!!!!!
WINNER: Time ATAC